Discussion:
Smell of natural gas from engine cmprtmt?
(too old to reply)
frenchy
2009-08-13 06:14:27 UTC
Permalink
My 2000 GMC has started to have a very strong odor of natural gas
coming from the front. If I drive with the windows open even a
little, it comes pouring in. Windows closed with or w/o the a/c on,
absolutely nothing. Really weird, it is the *exact* same smell of
home gas when you turn on the stove, you know, that odor they put in
it so you know there's a gas leak? We even thought at first I had
forgot to turn the gas off in the trailer we were pulling, but nope
that was not it.

There is nothing leaking onto the ground anywhere and the truck runs
fine, recently had it all checked out and fluids changed. Any idea
what fluid in the car would smell exactly like this and why it would
be so strong coming in when the side windows are open? Or what part
might smell like that if it was burning or something?

thanks
Frenchy
Jerry - OHIO
2009-08-13 17:42:16 UTC
Permalink
Oxagen sensor ?? My GMC stunk like that . I got lucky ,brother unpluged
it as a juke. He still hasn't figured out who took his valve stem cores
five years later. I have a verry good memory. BTW I did that right
after his wedding.

Jerry


http://community.webtv.net/awoodbutcher/MyWoodWorkingPage



http://community.webtv.net/awoodbutcher/1974RuppCentair
Augustus
2009-08-14 16:12:48 UTC
Permalink
Post by frenchy
My 2000 GMC has started to have a very strong odor of natural gas
coming from the front. If I drive with the windows open even a
little, it comes pouring in. Windows closed with or w/o the a/c on,
absolutely nothing. Really weird, it is the *exact* same smell of
home gas when you turn on the stove, you know, that odor they put in
it so you know there's a gas leak? We even thought at first I had
forgot to turn the gas off in the trailer we were pulling, but nope
that was not it.
The odorant they put in natural gas is methyl mercaptan...there's nothing in
a vehicle's systems containing this compound. When you eat asparagus, this
is the stuff that makes your urine stink afterwards. A catalytic converter
at operating temperature produces small quantities hydrogen sulfide which is
a powerful odorant (rotten egg smell), detectable at a few ppm by people.
It's usually released and from the coverter after low temp operation when
it's adsorbed by internal cat washcoat and released on high temp operation
of the cat. Unless the exhaust system is leaking past the converter and
seeping from under the car to the front and sides this is usually only
detectable from rear. Is it possible you are smelling exhaust gasses wafting
back from the pipe?
Pete C.
2009-08-14 18:16:55 UTC
Permalink
Post by Augustus
Post by frenchy
My 2000 GMC has started to have a very strong odor of natural gas
coming from the front. If I drive with the windows open even a
little, it comes pouring in. Windows closed with or w/o the a/c on,
absolutely nothing. Really weird, it is the *exact* same smell of
home gas when you turn on the stove, you know, that odor they put in
it so you know there's a gas leak? We even thought at first I had
forgot to turn the gas off in the trailer we were pulling, but nope
that was not it.
The odorant they put in natural gas is methyl mercaptan...there's nothing in
a vehicle's systems containing this compound. When you eat asparagus, this
is the stuff that makes your urine stink afterwards. A catalytic converter
at operating temperature produces small quantities hydrogen sulfide which is
a powerful odorant (rotten egg smell), detectable at a few ppm by people.
It's usually released and from the coverter after low temp operation when
it's adsorbed by internal cat washcoat and released on high temp operation
of the cat. Unless the exhaust system is leaking past the converter and
seeping from under the car to the front and sides this is usually only
detectable from rear. Is it possible you are smelling exhaust gasses wafting
back from the pipe?
More likely that the battery is overcharging and boiling off sulfuric
acid fumes.
webmoney
2009-08-14 18:51:14 UTC
Permalink
On Wed, 12 Aug 2009 23:14:27 -0700 (PDT), frenchy
Post by frenchy
My 2000 GMC has started to have a very strong odor of natural gas
coming from the front. If I drive with the windows open even a
little, it comes pouring in. Windows closed with or w/o the a/c on,
absolutely nothing. Really weird, it is the *exact* same smell of
home gas when you turn on the stove, you know, that odor they put in
it so you know there's a gas leak? We even thought at first I had
forgot to turn the gas off in the trailer we were pulling, but nope
that was not it.
There is nothing leaking onto the ground anywhere and the truck runs
fine, recently had it all checked out and fluids changed. Any idea
what fluid in the car would smell exactly like this and why it would
be so strong coming in when the side windows are open? Or what part
might smell like that if it was burning or something?
thanks
Frenchy
I guess that you have checked and sniffed all fluids
from engine compartment, checked belt tensions.
Checked that there is no bearing burning out from
alternator, checked that auxiliary electric cooling fans
are not jammed and burning hot..

That smell could come from car battery.

Check battery water levels if you dont't have
maintenance free battery. fill if necessary. Check also
that there is not overfilling in any of the cells.
Check charging voltage at different engine revs. 14.2V
max would be ok.
Usually US made alternators charge little bit higher
level than EU made automobiles.
Check battery voltage with engine turned off. put some
load for battery, lights on and check that battery level
won't drop excessively. This is to check that there is
no battery cells shorted.
This all is to check that there is no battery over
charging at any cells or whole battery that would boil
the battery water and overspill battery water thorough
overspill tube or blowing boiling gases out of the
overspill tube or water filling caps. (Hydrogen, Oxygen)
Clean battery and check that there is no cracks or
leaks. Also check that battery is in its original
shape, not ballooned or otherwise disformed.
Grease battery connections with oxygen free grease or
battery spray. Check also battery connections and that
the battery is solidly installed.

If that smell doesn't come from battery, at least your
battery is now overhauled.

--

Or that smell could come from raccoon that is half
rotten and stucked in your radiator (c:)>

AJ.

_____________________________
Gas price at the moment $7.30/gal
8-12 miles /gal with Chevy SS454
_____________________________
frenchy
2009-08-14 21:28:22 UTC
Permalink
Thanks I'll check out the battery levels and the voltage, the voltage
gauge seems to read ok, and will check the fan. This is definitely
not wafting up from the rear, that's what we thought at first since we
first noticed it with the trailer back there, but even with no trailer
it is exactly the same amount of stink from the windows while driving.
I'm almost positive it is not some other fluid in the car as I'm
familiar with their smells. Also it is definitely not that rotten-egg
smell associated with cat convertors, so pretty sure it's not an
exhaust leak, just doesn't smell like an exhaust, fuel or cat conv.
odor. The racoon joke is almost what I thought at first, I started
hunting for some dead cat under the hood. I suppose their could be an
animal hidden somewhere that I can't see it, this did happen first
when we left a camping area, I'll look some more.
Thanks everybody!
Mark
frenchy
2009-08-14 21:43:17 UTC
Permalink
I just went out to the parking lot... battery looks fine, all cells
are filled and identical, cell caps are on good, no bulging or leaks,
terminals are nice and clean, dash gauge reads slightly above 14
volts. Belts are all new and look fine and correct tightness. Man
I'm really starting to think maybe there may be a critter stuck
somewhere under the truck after all, time to get out the work light
tonight in the garage. That's the first thing I thought of when I
smelled it!
Mark
Steve W.
2009-08-15 00:07:09 UTC
Permalink
Post by frenchy
I just went out to the parking lot... battery looks fine, all cells
are filled and identical, cell caps are on good, no bulging or leaks,
terminals are nice and clean, dash gauge reads slightly above 14
volts. Belts are all new and look fine and correct tightness. Man
I'm really starting to think maybe there may be a critter stuck
somewhere under the truck after all, time to get out the work light
tonight in the garage. That's the first thing I thought of when I
smelled it!
Mark
Could be a cooked critter over the cat. Not a fun thing to clean up.
Wasn't anyone around the campsite who had some human scent masking
product? A bit of the stuff I use to hide my scent from animals while
heading to the tree stand could sure make a stink. (I know it can
because some A%%WIPE poured about a tablespoon of skunk musk in the
window wash jug on the truck a few years ago... The only way I got rid
of that was to replace the tubing, jug and pump!!!!)
--
Steve W.
None4U
2009-08-15 00:17:38 UTC
Permalink
Post by Steve W.
Post by frenchy
I just went out to the parking lot... battery looks fine, all cells
are filled and identical, cell caps are on good, no bulging or leaks,
terminals are nice and clean, dash gauge reads slightly above 14
volts. Belts are all new and look fine and correct tightness. Man
I'm really starting to think maybe there may be a critter stuck
somewhere under the truck after all, time to get out the work light
tonight in the garage. That's the first thing I thought of when I
smelled it!
Mark
Could be a cooked critter over the cat. Not a fun thing to clean up.
Wasn't anyone around the campsite who had some human scent masking
product? A bit of the stuff I use to hide my scent from animals while
heading to the tree stand could sure make a stink. (I know it can
because some A%%WIPE poured about a tablespoon of skunk musk in the
window wash jug on the truck a few years ago... The only way I got rid
of that was to replace the tubing, jug and pump!!!!)
--
Steve W.
Thanks for the laugh...
Tim
2009-08-15 04:50:09 UTC
Permalink
Post by frenchy
Thanks I'll check out the battery levels and the voltage, the voltage
gauge seems to read ok, and will check the fan. This is definitely
not wafting up from the rear, that's what we thought at first since we
first noticed it with the trailer back there, but even with no trailer
it is exactly the same amount of stink from the windows while driving.
I'm almost positive it is not some other fluid in the car as I'm
familiar with their smells. Also it is definitely not that rotten-egg
smell associated with cat convertors, so pretty sure it's not an
exhaust leak, just doesn't smell like an exhaust, fuel or cat conv.
odor. The racoon joke is almost what I thought at first, I started
hunting for some dead cat under the hood. I suppose their could be an
animal hidden somewhere that I can't see it, this did happen first
when we left a camping area, I'll look some more.
Thanks everybody!
Mark
How long has it been a problem? If a dead animal is the cause, it's not
likely to cause a problem, or at least one of this magnitude, for more than
one or two weeks.
frenchy
2009-08-15 08:31:26 UTC
Permalink
Post by Tim
How long has it been a problem? If a dead animal is the cause, it's not
likely to cause a problem, or at least one of this magnitude,  for more than
one or two weeks.>>
Been about two months, same now as when first noticed. I whiffed it
again today on the way home and by golly, maybe it *could* be the
smell of exhaust. Not a rotten egg odor but I'm thinking it
definitely could just be an exhaust smell. I don't smell it at all
when I pop the hood open, just driving. So perhaps it is somewhere
aft of but close to the engine, where it could make it up to the side
windows but not be in the engine compartment. I'm going to take it to
the dealer and have them take a look, I don't want to get poisoned to
death, if that's what it is.
If it was the exhaust, how far forward would the leak have to be for
it to come in strong thru the windows at speed? I'd think it has to
be a pretty big leak for all the smell I'm getting, but I don't hear
any odd noise like an exhaust hole.
Tim
2009-08-15 11:37:35 UTC
Permalink
Post by Tim
How long has it been a problem? If a dead animal is the cause, it's not
likely to cause a problem, or at least one of this magnitude, for more
than
one or two weeks.>>
-Been about two months, same now as when first noticed. I whiffed it
-again today on the way home and by golly, maybe it *could* be the
-smell of exhaust. Not a rotten egg odor but I'm thinking it
-definitely could just be an exhaust smell. I don't smell it at all
-when I pop the hood open, just driving. So perhaps it is somewhere
-aft of but close to the engine, where it could make it up to the side
-windows but not be in the engine compartment. I'm going to take it to
-the dealer and have them take a look, I don't want to get poisoned to
-death, if that's what it is.
-If it was the exhaust, how far forward would the leak have to be for
-it to come in strong thru the windows at speed? I'd think it has to
-be a pretty big leak for all the smell I'm getting, but I don't hear
-any odd noise like an exhaust hole.

Do you have a camper window? There is usually a positive pressure on the
back window. Other than that I'm not sure. Might be a good idea to let a
muffler shop inspect the exhaust system.
frenchy
2009-08-16 03:14:39 UTC
Permalink
Post by Tim
Do you have a camper window? There is usually a positive pressure on the
back window. Other than that I'm not sure. Might be a good idea to let a
muffler shop inspect the exhaust system.>>
No, solid rear window. Muffler shop is a good idea, since now I'm 90%
sure it is exhaust gas, thanks, will do.
When my a/c system is set to 'fresh air', does it draw the air in from
the vent at the bottom of the windshield, or from somewhere else? I
definitely do not smell anything when using the vents and a/c blower.
Till I get it figured out I have to drive it with the windows up and
the ventilation fan on, or else it's stink-a-rama.
Tim
2009-08-16 16:36:57 UTC
Permalink
Post by frenchy
Post by Tim
Do you have a camper window? There is usually a positive pressure on the
back window. Other than that I'm not sure. Might be a good idea to let a
muffler shop inspect the exhaust system.>>
No, solid rear window. Muffler shop is a good idea, since now I'm 90%
sure it is exhaust gas, thanks, will do.
When my a/c system is set to 'fresh air', does it draw the air in from
the vent at the bottom of the windshield, or from somewhere else? I
definitely do not smell anything when using the vents and a/c blower.
Till I get it figured out I have to drive it with the windows up and
the ventilation fan on, or else it's stink-a-rama.
As far as I know, all your vent air comes from the base of the windshield.
But you have a rubber strip along the back of the hood, that does a good job
of the keeping engine compartment air from reaching it. All engine air leaks
would be outside that seal. Lift your hood and you can easily inspect it,
and it's length compared to the windshield vent.

Do you have ANY aftermarket equipment installed? Something that might effect
the ventilation of the engine compartment. Maybe an oil cooler or something?

I used to have a car that whistled at highway speeds. You never heard it,
unless you drove under and underpass or something. I never figured out why.
m***@gmail.com
2014-04-25 13:00:46 UTC
Permalink
Just wondering if you ever resolved this smell of natural gas in your car, I have it in my honda CRV,
Marci M
2017-12-09 05:18:04 UTC
Permalink
replying to mckeon1960, Marci M wrote:
I have it in my Mazda CX-9 as well and was wondering if this was ever resolved.

--
for full context, visit http://www.motorsforum.com/chevy_trucks/smell-of-natural-gas-from-engine-cmprtmt-16371-.htm
a***@gmail.com
2017-12-27 22:58:12 UTC
Permalink
I have this in my Mazda cx-9 as well! Did you figure out the reason for the smell??
yehwhatevr
2018-01-18 15:18:01 UTC
Permalink
replying to ashleymvalentine1991, yehwhatevr wrote:
No, I have not received any further comments about this... The majority of the
comments refer to the oxygen sensor so I'm going to ask my mechanic.

--
for full context, visit http://www.motorsforum.com/chevy_trucks/smell-of-natural-gas-from-engine-cmprtmt-16371-.htm
KWKy
2018-03-05 15:18:02 UTC
Permalink
replying to ashleymvalentine1991, KWKy wrote:
Have you had any luck. My 2011 CX9 just started as well

--
for full context, visit https://www.motorsforum.com/chevy_trucks/smell-of-natural-gas-from-engine-cmprtmt-16371-.htm
yehwhatevr
2018-01-18 15:18:03 UTC
Permalink
replying to mckeon1960, yehwhatevr wrote:
No, I have not received any further comments about this... The majority of the
comments refer to the oxygen sensor so I'm going to ask my mechanic.

--
for full context, visit http://www.motorsforum.com/chevy_trucks/smell-of-natural-gas-from-engine-cmprtmt-16371-.htm
Loading...